Penn got off to a fast start, winning each of the first three matches by decision to take a 9-0 team lead. Mark Rappo was an 8-3 winner at 125 pounds, followed by Bryan Ortenzio at 133 (5-2) and Zack Kemmerer at 141 (5-4).
Rider got back into the match when Michael Kessler defeated Troy Hernandez at 149 pounds, 6-3, and then Matt Dragon was unable to complete his match and injury defaulted at 157. That tied the match at 9-9 at the midway point.
Gabriel Burak righted the ship for the Quakers, dominating Rob Morrison to gain a technical fall with a minute left in the third period. Following that, Scott Giffin gained a 13-0 win over Jim Resnick which put the Quakers up 18-9.
Rider got three points back at 184 pounds, as Mike Ward defeated Cory Beaver, but Micah Burak took advantage of a pre-match injury suffered by Rider's Tyler Smith and defeated the 20th-ranked wrestler in the country at 197 pounds, 6-0. That put the team score out of reach, and Ed Bordas' heavyweight win over Tyler Blakely was not enough.
125 - Mark Rappo (P) def. Ilyass Elmasouri (R), 8-3 (Penn 3-0)
133 - Bryan Ortenzio (P) def.Filiberto Colon (R), 5-2 (Penn 6-0)
141 - Zack Kemmerer (P) def. Aaron Nestor (R), 5-4 (Penn 9-0)
149 - Michael Kessler (R) def. Troy Hernandez (P), 6-3 (Penn 9-3)
157 - Zac Cibula (R) def. #16 Matt Dragon (P), injury default 4:20 (tied 9-9)
165 - #20 Gabriel Burak (P) def. Rob Morrison (R), tech fall 6:00 (Penn 14-9)
174 - Scott Giffin (P) def. Jim Resnick (R), 13-0 (Penn 18-9)
184 - Mike Ward (R) def. Cory Beaver (P), 8-4 (Penn 18-12)
197 - Micah Burak (P) def. #20 Tyler Smith (R), 6-0 (Penn 21-12)
285 - Ed Bordas (R) def. Tyler Blakely (P), 5-1